Home / Resources / Law Firm Marketing

Law Firm Marketing

Volume Is a Cost: Why Law Firms Chasing More Enquiries Are Getting Poorer

Most law firm marketing is built on a lie so common nobody notices it any more: that more is better.

More enquiries. More leads. More consultations. More matters. Lower cost per lead. Every agency report, every partner meeting and every marketing dashboard is designed to celebrate volume.

Les Binet thinks that's backwards. And when it comes to law firms, I think he's more right than he knows.

Binet, co-author of The Long and the Short of It and the most influential effectiveness researcher in modern marketing, put it bluntly in a recent interview on the Behavioral Science for Brands podcast, quoting the late Professor Peter Doyle: volume is a cost to a business, not a benefit. Profit is the goal. Revenue is good. Volume is bad. And most of what passes for "growth marketing" pushes volume up and revenue down.

Binet was talking about chocolate bars, shampoo and toilet paper. But there's no category on earth where volume is more obviously a cost than legal services. Every matter a firm takes on consumes the one thing it can't manufacture more of: a lawyer's time.

The physics of a law firm

A shampoo factory can run another shift. A law firm can't run another lawyer.

That's what makes the volume obsession so destructive in legal services. A firm's capacity is fixed in the short term by the number of lawyers it has and the hours they can work. Every low-value matter you win is a high-value matter you no longer have time for.

And the hours are already tighter than most partners admit. Clio's Legal Trends benchmarks for 2025 put average utilisation at 38%, about 3.0 billable hours in an eight-hour day. Realisation was 88%, so only about 2.6 hours a day were actually invoiced. Collection was 93%, so about 2.4 hours a day were actually paid (Clio, Law Firm KPIs). Those are US figures from Clio's user base, not an Australian benchmark, but anyone who has run a practice will recognise the shape.

Now look at what most law firm marketing is designed to do: fill that limited day with more. More "quick questions". More free first consultations. More enquiries from people who can't afford you, don't qualify, or were never going to instruct anyone. Each one costs intake time, lawyer time and attention, and most of it never shows up on a marketing report as a cost.

A marketing report that says "enquiries up 40%" might be describing a firm that just got poorer.

Law firms have their own version of the price promotion habit

Binet's newest research, Kicking the Promotion Habit, presented with Kantar's Dom Boyd at the IPA Effectiveness Conference in October 2026, is about price promotions. Its findings are devastating (IPA, 2026):

  • Around two-thirds of price promotions lose money, based on the wider body of evidence the research reviewed.
  • Promotions are the largest single component of marketing spend, around twice the size of paid media advertising.
  • 75% of the senior marketers surveyed couldn't estimate what share of their promotions were profitable.
  • 76% repeat promotions even when their profitability hasn't been assessed.
  • 81% evaluate promotions over periods shorter than 13 weeks, too short to see the long-term damage.

Binet's verdict: price promotions are "like class A drugs: expensive, dangerous and addictive."

Law firms don't run buy-one-get-one-free deals. But they have their own version of the promotion habit, and it's everywhere:

  • The free first consultation, offered to everyone, qualified or not, and quietly consuming senior lawyer hours every week.
  • The fixed-fee price war, where firms advertise a lower conveyancing or wills fee than the firm down the road and then wonder why margins disappeared.
  • "We'll match any quote", which tells every client that your price is negotiable and your work is a commodity.
  • Bought leads, where lead-generation platforms sell the same enquiry to several firms and the cheapest responder wins.
  • The cheapest cost per lead, where agencies are rewarded for driving enquiry volume at the lowest possible price, regardless of what those enquiries are worth.

Each one produces a short-term volume hit that looks great on a dashboard. Each one has a cost that rarely gets measured: lawyer time, lower realised rates, and clients who arrive expecting to pay less.

Discounting teaches the market your real price

The most chilling story in Binet's interview isn't about profit. It's about memory.

He describes a premium brand of wet wipes that launched at nearly £4 a packet. It couldn't resist running price promotions. Shoppers soon learned there would always be a shop somewhere with them on deal, so they stopped paying full price. Twenty years later, the same product typically sells for 99p. The discounts didn't just cost margin at the time. They permanently taught the market what the product was "really" worth.

Law firms do this too, just more slowly and less visibly.

A firm that leads with "affordable", "low-cost", "fixed fees from $X" or "free consultation" isn't just running a promotion. It's positioning itself as a price-led firm in the minds of clients, referrers and, increasingly, AI systems that summarise what the market says about you. Once the market decides you're the cheap option, the clients you attract are the ones shopping on price, and they're the least loyal, the most demanding and the least profitable clients you'll ever have.

As Binet points out, it's much easier to start as a premium brand and lose that position than to start cheap and climb out.

Pricing power is the whole game

Warren Buffett told the US Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission in 2010 that the single most important decision in evaluating a business is pricing power: the ability to raise prices without losing business to a competitor (FCIC interview transcript).

For a law firm, pricing power is the difference between being chosen and being compared.

A firm with pricing power gets instructed by clients who've already decided they want that firm. They don't ask for three quotes. They don't negotiate the fee. They're referred by accountants who say "you need to see them". They come from people who've watched the firm's lawyers explain things clearly for years.

A firm without pricing power competes on price for every matter, wins the clients nobody else wanted at a margin nobody else would accept, and then spends more on marketing to replace the margin it gave away.

Binet's career-long finding is that pricing power is built through brand: emotional, broad-reach, consistent marketing that makes a business famous and trusted over time. Activation and discounting do the opposite. They make you more visible to price-sensitive buyers and less valuable to everyone else. We unpack the research on this in why performance marketing fails law firms.

Your agency's favourite number is the wrong one

Binet's other recent report, Go Big or Go Home, written with Medialab's Will Davis and presented at the IPA Effectiveness Conference in 2025, attacks another sacred metric: return on investment (IPA, 2025).

When they surveyed 500 senior marketers, 65% said ROI was the most important contributor to marketing effectiveness and only 35% said budget. Then they analysed the IPA's effectiveness case studies. Budget accounted for 89% of the variation in payback; ROI accounted for 11%. In other words, budget was about eight times more important than efficiency.

They also found that since Covid, ROI has risen 4% while net profit has fallen 11%. Marketers got more efficient and businesses made less money. Binet warns of a "death spiral" of budgets, campaigns and profits all getting smaller.

His physics analogy in the interview is worth remembering. You can very efficiently hardly move something at all. Put in £1 and get £10 back: brilliant ROI, £10 of profit. Put in £1 million and get £2 million back: worse ROI, £1 million more profit. A business trying to make money should prefer the second every time.

Now look at how most law firms judge their marketing: cost per lead, cost per click, ROI by channel, month by month. Those numbers are useful to the specialists running the campaigns. As a way of deciding how much to invest and where, they're actively dangerous. They reward the cheapest, narrowest, most short-term activity, and they make the firm smaller.

I'd go further than Binet here, because law firms have a problem consumer brands don't. Their "ROI" figures are usually built on enquiry volume, not on profit per matter, because most firms can't connect a marketing source to the fees eventually collected. So law firms aren't just optimising the wrong metric. They're often optimising a guess.

The elite quarter

There's one encouraging finding in Binet's interview. Among the marketers surveyed, he describes a group of roughly a quarter who were different. They estimated, accurately, that most promotions in their industry were unprofitable, and they believed their own were less so. What distinguished them was simple: formal training, familiarity with the research, and proper evaluation programmes.

Law firms can join that elite quarter without a research budget. It mostly takes the discipline to measure the right things:

  • Profit per matter by source, not cost per lead. If you don't know which sources produce your most profitable matters, start recording it. See how to track law firm marketing to file opens, not clicks.
  • Enquiry quality, not enquiry volume. Track the share of enquiries that are in your priority practice areas, can afford you and convert.
  • Realised rate and write-offs by source. If clients from one channel consistently negotiate fees down or don't pay, that channel is costing you money.
  • The right time horizon. Binet's survey found 81% of marketers evaluate promotions over less than 13 weeks. Most law firms judge marketing monthly. Brand effects take years. Judge activation monthly and brand annually.

When discounting does make sense

To be fair to Binet, he's not saying never discount. The research shows price promotions can work in specific conditions, and some translate to legal services:

  • When the capacity would otherwise be wasted. Binet's example is an airline seat that will fly empty anyway. For a law firm, that might be a newly hired lawyer with genuinely spare capacity. Even then, discount deliberately, temporarily and to a defined group, not publicly and forever.
  • When you're genuinely new and need first clients. A new firm or practice area has no existing clients to subsidise, so an introductory offer is more likely to bring in genuinely new work. Beware Binet's "low price trap", though: once clients think of you as cheap, you'll struggle to get out.
  • When you add value instead of cutting price. Binet distinguishes price promotions from added-value promotions, which tend to be more profitable and better for brands. For a law firm, that means a clear fixed-fee scope, a faster response, a useful guide, or a proper strategy session, rather than knocking dollars off the fee.

What to stop doing

Here's where I'd start, in order:

  1. Stop reporting enquiry volume as success. Replace "enquiries this month" with qualified enquiries, consultations and opened matters in priority practice areas, and what they're worth. See law firm performance reporting.
  2. Stop giving away senior time indiscriminately. If you offer a free first consultation, qualify it first through proper intake. Senior lawyer time should go to matters you want.
  3. Stop advertising on price. "Affordable", "cheap", "lowest fees" and "we'll beat any quote" all buy short-term volume by permanently lowering what the market thinks you're worth.
  4. Stop buying shared leads. Paying for enquiries that are sold to several firms trains you to compete on speed and price, and builds someone else's brand.
  5. Stop judging marketing by ROI alone. Ask how much profit each channel generates over a year, not how efficiently it generates enquiries this month. See how to build a smarter law firm marketing budget.
  6. Stop underinvesting. Binet's most uncomfortable finding is that the size of the budget matters more than how efficiently it's spent. If a firm wants to be the obvious choice in its market, it has to be visible to that market at scale, consistently, for years. See law firm brand strategy.

The uncomfortable conclusion

Most law firms don't have a marketing problem. They have a volume addiction.

They measure success by how many people contact them, reward agencies for producing more of those contacts at lower cost, give away senior time to anyone who asks, compete on price because their brand isn't strong enough to compete on anything else, and then wonder why the partners are working harder for less.

The firms that will win the next decade will be the ones that get this the right way round. They'll want fewer, better matters. They'll measure profit, not volume. They'll invest enough to become famous in their market. They'll protect their pricing power rather than trade it away for a busy month. And they'll be comfortable turning work away.

As Binet says of his own consultancy: he never discounts. When clients ask for a better price, he asks whether they've ever read his work.

Law firms could learn a lot from that answer.

If you'd like to know where your firm's most profitable work actually comes from, and what it costs you to chase the rest, get a free audit.

Where does your most profitable work come from?Our free audit shows which sources bring profitable matters, what chasing the rest costs you, and what to fix first.
Get a Free Audit →

Sources

Dan Toombs, Lawyer and Founder of Practice Proof
Written by

Dan Toombs

Lawyer & Founder, Practice Proof

Dan Toombs is a lawyer, law reformer and founder of Practice Proof. Admitted in 1997, he built his first career inside the legal profession — practising law, leading legal organisations and driving law reform — before building the marketing, technology and AI practice he has now run exclusively for law firms for 20 years.

In that time, Dan and his team have helped law firms grow from single offices into multi-office and national practices, ASX-listed brands and acquisition targets. That experience gives Practice Proof an unusually deep understanding of both sides of law firm growth: what happens inside a legal practice, and what it takes commercially to make one grow.

Thomson Reuters featured his law-firm marketing advice as early as 2014, on positioning firms to win business online, websites and social media. He is also the founder of FirmRanker, which researches how AI systems discover and recommend law firms. Dan is a Winston Churchill Fellow and Australia Leadership Award recipient, with national recognition for his work in law and human rights.

If you want to know what 20 years of growing law firms could bring to yours, talk to Dan and the Practice Proof team.

HomeWhy We ExistHow We WorkWhat We DoWho We Work WithResultsInsightsContactGet a Free Audit →